Skip to main content
Self-Hosting & Privacy

Proton Drive vs Tresorit vs Nextcloud

Proton Drive, Tresorit, and self-hosted Nextcloud compared on real November 2026 pricing: what each costs per GB, who holds the encryption key, and what running Nextcloud on a home Proxmox server actually involves day to day.

Milan BuhaNovember 21, 20266 min read
ShareXin
Proton Drive vs Tresorit vs Nextcloud

Proton Drive vs Tresorit vs Nextcloud

Google Drive just sent another "you're almost out of storage, upgrade now" email, and the real question underneath it isn't the price — it's who else can actually read what's in those files. That question has three real answers: pay a zero-knowledge provider to hold your files without being able to open them, pay a stricter one built for audit trails, or run the storage yourself.

TL;DR

  • Zero-knowledge means the provider stores your files encrypted and never holds the key — Proton Drive and Tresorit both work this way; a standard Google Drive or Dropbox account does not.
  • Proton Drive's paid tiers run from 200 GB to 3 TB; Tresorit's personal tiers run from 50 GB to 4 TB with a stronger audit/compliance angle, at a higher price per GB.
  • Self-hosted Nextcloud is the only option with no company holding your keys at all — but it trades that for becoming your own sysadmin.
  • The real cost of self-hosting isn't the storage, it's the maintenance time, unless the hardware is already running 24/7 for something else.
  • Pick Proton Drive for zero setup, Tresorit for compliance needs, Nextcloud only if you already run (or want to run) a home server.

"Private" Cloud Storage Has Two Different Meanings

The SERP for this topic collapses two different privacy models into one phrase, and mixing them up is how people end up disappointed with whichever one they pick.

Zero-knowledge means the provider's servers only ever hold encrypted blobs — the encryption key lives on your device, so the company itself cannot open your files even if compelled to. Proton Drive and Tresorit both work this way.

Self-hosted means there's no third-party server at all. Nextcloud is the open-source software, not a hosting company — you (or a VPS you rent) run it, which means nobody but you ever holds the encryption key, the metadata, or the files, because nobody but you ever has them.

Note

a zero-knowledge provider still knows roughly how much storage you use and when you access it, even if it can't see file contents. Self-hosting is the only option that removes a third party from that picture entirely.

Proton Drive: Zero Setup, One Company Holding the Keys

Proton Drive's free tier gives 5 GB, enough to test the zero-knowledge model without committing. The paid tiers scale from there: Drive Plus at 200 GB for $4.99/month, Proton Unlimited at 500 GB for $12.99/month (which also bundles Proton Mail, Calendar, Pass, and VPN), Proton Duo at 2 TB for two people, and Proton Family at 3 TB for up to six at $29.99/month, all listed at their regular, non-promotional rates on Proton's own pricing page.

The appeal is that there's nothing to install or maintain — sign up, and the zero-knowledge encryption is already running. The tradeoff is that one Swiss company now holds the only copy of your encrypted data, and your account is subject to whatever jurisdiction and outage risk comes with trusting a single provider, the same tradeoff covered for DNS in our encrypted DNS explainer. One real gap: Proton's own apps page lists Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, and web clients, but no native Linux sync app — Linux-first workflows are limited to the web interface or its CLI tool.

Tresorit: Built for Audit Trails, Not for Price

Tresorit targets the same zero-knowledge model as Proton Drive but leans toward business and compliance use: detailed access logs, granular sharing permissions, and a longer audit history. Its personal tiers, as listed on Tresorit's own pricing page, are Personal Lite at 50 GB, Personal Essential at 1 TB, and Personal Pro at 4 TB — current pricing for each sits behind a billing-cycle toggle on that same page, worth checking directly since it genuinely changes with promotions.

If the only reason to consider Tresorit is "it sounds more secure," it isn't — both use zero-knowledge encryption. Tresorit's case is the audit-log and granular access-control depth, which matters for business compliance and barely registers for everyday personal use.

Self-Hosted Nextcloud: What It Actually Costs to Run

4 TBraw storage on my homelab's Nextcloud instance, running on a Proxmox box that's already powered on for other services, my homelab

Nextcloud is free, open-source software — there's no subscription, because there's no company hosting it for you. What it costs instead is time: an afternoon getting it installed and reverse-proxied for remote access, then an ongoing habit of applying updates and watching that backups actually run, since nobody else is doing that for you.

On hardware that's already running around the clock for other things — which describes most home Proxmox setups — the marginal cost of adding Nextcloud is close to zero: it's spare disk space on a machine already drawing power. The honest cost floor for someone without that hardware: a Hetzner Storage Box starts at €3.20/month for 1 TB of raw storage, plus a small always-on machine to actually run the Nextcloud application against it — the cheapest Hetzner Cloud VPS adds €5.49/month — a simple sum of those two listed rates puts the floor at roughly €8.69/month total before you've saved a single file.

Tip

before self-hosting anything for privacy reasons, as covered in our complete privacy toolkit, set a real backup target before day one — a self-hosted instance that is the only copy of your files is a worse privacy outcome than a zero-knowledge provider's redundant storage, no matter how private the setup looks.

Cost Per GB, Side by Side

Option Storage Monthly cost Who holds the key
Proton Drive Plus 200 GB $4.99 Proton
Proton Unlimited 500 GB $12.99 Proton
Proton Family 3 TB (6 users) $29.99 Proton
Nextcloud on existing homelab hardware As much as the drive holds ~$0 marginal You
Nextcloud on rented Hetzner Storage Box + VPS 1 TB ~€8.69 (storage + compute) You

Tresorit isn't in this table because its live pricing page renders dollar figures client-side rather than in fetchable text — quoting a number here risked printing something already stale. Its storage tiers (50 GB / 1 TB / 4 TB) are real; check its own pricing page for the current rate before buying.

Dividing those listed rates by their storage puts Proton Unlimited at roughly $0.026 per GB per month, and Proton Family at roughly $0.01 per GB once six people split 3 TB. Nothing beats the ~$0 marginal cost of adding a drive to hardware you're already running — the catch is that "free" only holds if the hardware and your time stay free too.

Which One to Actually Pick

The deciding factor is infrastructure, not fear: what's already running determines which of the three actually makes sense. No server and no interest in running one → Proton Drive, since it bundles a password manager and VPN most people end up paying for separately anyway. An actual audit-trail or business-compliance requirement → Tresorit, and nowhere else, since that's the entire reason its price sits above Proton's. A homelab already running, or a genuine interest in building one → self-hosted Nextcloud, the only option where no outside company ever holds the key. As with the privacy tools in our virtual-card comparison, the right tool is the one that matches infrastructure already in place, not the one with the best marketing page.

FAQ

Is Proton Drive actually private?

Yes, in the sense that matters most: it uses zero-knowledge encryption, so Proton's own servers never hold the key needed to read your files. Proton still knows metadata like how much storage you use and roughly when you access it.

What is zero-knowledge encryption in cloud storage?

It means the provider stores your files encrypted and never has the decryption key — only your device does. Even if the provider's servers were seized or subpoenaed, the files on them would be unreadable without a key the provider never possessed.

Is it safe to self-host Nextcloud for sensitive files?

It's as safe as you keep it — Nextcloud itself is mature, open-source software, but a self-hosted instance is only as secure as its patching schedule, backup discipline, and remote-access setup. An unpatched self-hosted server is a worse outcome than a maintained zero-knowledge provider.

Is Tresorit worth the price over Proton Drive?

Only if the audit trail and access-control features it's built for are an actual requirement — for example, business compliance. For personal use, Proton Drive provides the same zero-knowledge encryption at a lower price.

Related stories

More from Self-Hosting & Privacy

Stay in the loop

Get the latest articles delivered to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Read next

Self-Hosting Email vs Proton Mail: Worth It?

Self-hosting email sounds like the next homelab step after Tailscale and Docker. Here's why deliverability, not the DNS setup, is what actually breaks it, the real DKIM/SPF/DMARC config, and the honest cost vs Proton Mail.

Continue Reading